When planning a bathroom remodel in Chicago, one of the most common and important decisions homeowners face is choosing between a bathtub and a walk-in shower. This choice affects not only daily comfort and accessibility, but also remodeling cost and long-term resale value.
Chicago homes vary widely in age, layout, and buyer expectations, which makes this decision especially important. Understanding how bathtubs and walk-in showers compare in cost, function, and market appeal can help you make the right choice for your home and your goals.
The Difference Between a Bathtub and a Walk-In Shower
A bathtub is a traditional bathroom fixture designed for soaking and bathing. In Chicago homes, tubs are often found in older properties, family homes, and bathrooms designed to accommodate children. Bathtubs can be standalone, alcove-style, or part of a tub-and-shower combination.
A walk-in shower, on the other hand, is a shower enclosure without a tub. It typically features a low or zero-threshold entry, glass panels, and modern fixtures. Walk-in showers have become increasingly popular in Chicago bathroom remodels, especially in condos, townhomes, and homes focused on aging-in-place design.
Cost Comparison for Chicago Bathroom Remodels
Bathroom remodel cost is often the deciding factor for homeowners. In Chicago, installing a standard bathtub or tub-shower combo is usually less expensive than building a custom walk-in shower, particularly if plumbing locations remain unchanged.
Walk-in showers tend to cost more due to additional waterproofing, custom tile work, glass enclosures, and drainage systems. Curbless walk-in showers, which are especially popular in modern Chicago bathrooms, can increase costs further because of floor slope adjustments and plumbing modifications.
However, many homeowners see the higher upfront cost of a walk-in shower as an investment in comfort, accessibility, and resale appeal.
Accessibility and Everyday Use
Accessibility is one of the biggest advantages of walk-in showers. For Chicago homeowners planning to stay in their home long term, a walk-in shower offers safer entry, fewer tripping hazards, and easier use for all ages. This is particularly important in two-story homes or properties where the primary bathroom is expected to serve homeowners well into the future.
Bathtubs require stepping over a high edge, which can become a concern as mobility changes. That said, bathtubs remain practical for families with young children and for homeowners who value soaking as part of their routine.
In many Chicago bathroom remodels, homeowners choose to keep at least one bathtub in the home while converting secondary bathrooms to walk-in showers.
Space and Layout Considerations in Chicago Homes
Bathroom size plays a major role in this decision. Many Chicago condos and older homes have compact bathrooms where space efficiency matters. Walk-in showers can make a small bathroom feel larger and more open, especially when paired with glass enclosures and light tile.
Bathtubs typically take up more floor space and can make small bathrooms feel tighter. However, in larger primary bathrooms, a freestanding tub can serve as a design feature rather than a limitation.
Understanding your existing layout and plumbing is essential before deciding which option works best.
Resale Value in the Chicago Housing Market
Resale value is a key concern for homeowners remodeling with future buyers in mind. In Chicago, buyer expectations vary by neighborhood and property type, but one rule generally holds true: homes should have at least one bathtub to appeal to a broad range of buyers.
Walk-in showers are highly attractive in primary bathrooms and are often associated with modern, updated homes. Buyers frequently see them as a luxury feature, especially when designed with quality materials and thoughtful layout.
Removing all bathtubs from a home can limit buyer interest, while a balanced approach often delivers the best resale outcome.
When a Bathtub Makes More Sense
A bathtub is often the better choice if the home is family-oriented, if it currently lacks any tubs, or if the remodel is focused on maintaining traditional appeal. Bathtubs are also practical when budget constraints limit the scope of customization.
When a Walk-In Shower Is the Better Option
A walk-in shower is ideal for homeowners prioritizing accessibility, modern design, and daily convenience. It works especially well in primary bathrooms, smaller spaces, and homes where long-term comfort is a priority.
Final Thoughts on Bathtubs vs Walk-In Showers in Chicago
Choosing between a bathtub and a walk-in shower is not about following trends alone. It’s about aligning your bathroom remodel with how you use your home, how long you plan to stay, and what buyers in your Chicago market expect.
To make the right decision for your Chicago home, working with an experienced remodeling contractor matters. Budget Construction Company provides expert consultations and accurate estimates designed around your needs and budget.